BYU COUGARS

JJ & Alex: Is BYU Really Looking At Five Quarterbacks For Its Starter?

Aug 7, 2024, 1:38 PM

BYU Football, Spring Practice, Gerry Bohanon...

BYU football quarterback Gerry Bohanon took part in day one of spring practice on February 29, 2024. (Photo courtesy of BYU Photo)

(Photo courtesy of BYU Photo)

PROVO, Utah – The big question at BYU fall camp is the quarterback race, and head coach Kalani Sitake has made it clear he is in no rush to name a starter.

He wants as many reps and observations as possible before making the call on who the starter will be when the season gets underway against Southern Illinois.

“It is not a deadline thing. It is just a feel. Right now, I can tell you it is not going to happen this week,” Sitake said when fall camp opened last week. “Both guys did a great job. I mean, all four quarterbacks did a great job today.”

After spring practices, the assumption was that the starting job would come down to Baylor and USF transfer Gerry Bohanon or Jake Retzlaff who started four games for the Cougars in 2023.

However, Sitake has said a few times during fall camp that four quarterbacks are doing well.

BYU added two other quarterbacks via the transfer portal; the first was Treyson Bourguet out of Western Michigan and he participated in spring practices. The other portal QB arrived in April when McCae Hillstead left Utah State for the Cougars.

Those two additions were seen as potential future options with three years of eligibility left for each. Bohanon has one year and Retzlaff has two years left to play.

To get more quarterbacks live action and to evaluate them, the team has been splitting into groups to allow more chances for these quarterbacks to show what they can do during fall camp.

“We split it to get more reps. It is good for both sides, but it will tax on you a little bit. In order for us to get reps for everybody, and to compete, we have to do that,” Sitake said. “Their job is to make it hard on us making a decision, but I feel comfortable having a bunch of guys who can do it, so we will go with the best one. Right now, that one hasn’t stood out yet.”

BYU Expanding Quarterback Pool To Find Starter?

The latest in the quarterback race came when Sitake said four quarterbacks were getting better, but he also mentioned a fifth quarterback by name in redshirt freshman Cole Hagen who has been improving.

“They ​kind ​of ​go ​back ​and ​forth, ​and ​I ​don’t ​know ​if ​it’s ​enough ​yet ​to ​separate ​them,” Sitake said. “So, ​when ​we ​factor ​it ​all ​in, ​it’s ​just ​more ​who ​can ​get ​the ​team ​to ​execute ​the ​best ​and ​make ​sure ​that ​we’re ​not ​making ​mistakes. I ​want ​to ​see ​the ​progress ​of ​the ​quarterback ​position ​with ​all ​those ​guys ​and we ​talked ​about ​the ​four ​quarterbacks, ​but ​it’s ​also ​with ​Cole ​Hagen, ​so ​all ​the ​guys ​are ​getting ​better.”

Five BYU quarterbacks?

This is the first time Hagen’s name has been mentioned. Maybe that is intentional to keep players happy and not have an eye toward the portal.

Or maybe the Cougar’s head coach is just trying to throw people off the scent and keep things close to his chest?

Is This All A Smoke Screen?

On KSL Sports Zone’s JJ & Alex, both  Jeremiah Jensen and Alex Kirry are not so sure about those comments by Sitake. Both were surprised that a fifth quarterback was brought up.

“Kalani’s messing with us right?” Kirry asked. “When ​you ​have ​five ​quarterbacks, ​you ​have ​no ​quarterbacks. ​Isn’t ​that, ​the ​old ​saying?

“You then ​throw ​Cole ​Hagen’s ​name ​in ​there. ​I ​really ​do ​think ​that ​[BYU’s] ​like, ‘​look, ​​we ​don’t ​need ​to ​tell ​you ​guys ​anything. ​In ​fact, ​we’re ​not ​going ​to ​tell ​you ​anything.  Some ​mistakes ​were made ​today, ​and some ​picks ​were ​thrown.’ ​I’m ​like, ​there ​it ​is ​right ​there. ​Then ​cut ​those ​guys.”

Download the new & improved KSL Sports app from Utah’s sports leader. You can stream live radio, video and stay up to date on all of your favorite teams.

Jensen is trying to keep even-keeled regarding the quarterback race.

“I ​don’t ​want ​to ​overreact. ​I’m ​not ​sitting ​there ​watching ​these ​quarterbacks,” Jensen said. “​We’re ​just ​going ​by ​what ​Kalani ​is ​telling ​us. ​

“If ​you ​got ​five ​guys ​that ​are ​getting ​reps ​and ​your ​practices ​that ​you’re ​talking ​about ​with ​the ​media, , ​maybe ​there’s ​a ​smoke screen ​there. ​But ​I ​also ​think ​that ​there’s ​some ​truth ​in ​that, ​that ​they’re ​really ​searching ​here.”

One thought on these comments is that it is gamesmanship. BYU is telling the world about its expansive search for its starting quarterback to throw off future opponents.

Who will be BYU’s starting quarterback?

“This ​seems ​like ​a ​game ​that ​[Kalani Sitake is] ​playing ​a ​little ​bit ​with ​having ​to ​give ​you ​an ​answer, ​by ​not ​really ​wanting ​to ​give ​you ​anything,” Korry added. “Not ​giving ​you ​anything ​to ​the ​pile and ​that ​is, ​they ​got ​five ​quarterbacks ​who ​are ​all ​working ​out ​with ​the ​ones ​and ​twos.”

When the Cougars kick off against Southern Illinois on Aug. 31, it likely will be Retzlaff or Bohanon under center at quarterback.

Tune into JJ & Alex every Monday through Friday, 3-6 p.m. on 1280 AM and 97.5 FM, or subscribe to the podcast. Also, download the all-new KSL Sports app on iOS or Android.

  • BYU Cougars Scoreboard

  • BYU Cougars Team Leaders

  • BYU Cougars Standings

BYU Cougars

BYU Football, First Team, All-Big 12, Caleb Etienne...

Mitch Harper

Three BYU Football Players Receive First Team All-Big 12 Honors

BYU has First-Team All-Conference players for the first time in 14 years.

2 days ago

BYU Football, Signing Day, What We Learned...

Mitch Harper

Five Things We Learned From BYU’s Early Signing Day

Busy, productive day for BYU football to kick off the Early Signing Period.

3 days ago

AJ Dybantsa, Top Four, BYU Basketball, Utah Prep...

Mitch Harper

BYU Makes Top Four Cut For No. 1 Recruit AJ Dybantsa

AJ Dybantsa has BYU in his final four schools.

3 days ago

Jake Retzlaff...

Brian Preece

BYU QB Jake Retzlaff Lands Faith-Based NIL Deal

In a nod to his religious upbringing, Retzlaff signed a sponsorship deal with Jewish food brand Manischewitz as part of an NIL agreement.

3 days ago

BYU Football, Luke McGary, Transfer Portal Offer...

Mitch Harper

BYU Football Offers Transfer Portal TE From Tulsa

BYU football gets in the mix for a transfer portal tight end.

3 days ago

Polynesian Football Hall of Fame, Kalani Sitake, Chris Kemoeatu, BYU, Utah...

Mitch Harper

Kalani Sitake, Chris Kemoeatu Named To Polynesian Football Hall Of Fame

The 2025 class for the Polynesian Football Hall of Fame.

3 days ago

Sponsored Articles

salt lake county player of the week...

Salt Lake County High School Player of the Week – Week 15

SALT LAKE CITY – The Hercules Salt Lake County High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school football player in Salt Lake County. Presented by Hercules First Federal Credit Union, each week we honor athletes for their exceptional performance on the gridiron. Our co-winners this week were Esun Tafa and Cooper Kingston from […]

...

Utah County High School Player of the Week – Week 15

SALT LAKE CITY – The Mr. Mac Utah County High School Player of the Week is awarded each week to the top prep football players in Utah County. Sponsored by Mr. Mac, it honors athletes for their performances on the gridiron and exceptional play. Our co-winners this week were Aaron Dunn from Spanish Fork High School and […]

Rice-Eccles Stadium...

Crimson Cliffs Completes Epic Comeback To Win 4A State Championship

Crimson Cliffs needed the largest comeback in Utah state history to knock off the Spanish Fork Dons 57-55 in triple overtime.

corner canyon football celebrates win over lehi...

Corner Canyon Comes From Behind To Win 6A State Championship

The Corner Canyon Chargers fell behind early but didn't panic, scoring 23 straight points to beat Lone Peak 30-27.

Siaki Fekitoa...

Siaki Fekitoa’s Four TDs Lead Bountiful To 5A State Championship

Title Thursday started on a high note with a fireworks-filled offensive show as Bountiful held on to beat Roy 42-35.

...

Northern Utah High School Player of the Week – Week 14

SALT LAKE CITY – The John Watson Northern Utah High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school football player in Northern Utah. Presented by John Watson Chevrolet in Ogden, each week we honor athletes for their exceptional performance on the gridiron. Our co-winners of the week were Beck Sheffield from Morgan High School […]

JJ & Alex: Is BYU Really Looking At Five Quarterbacks For Its Starter?