NCAA

NCAA Votes To Accept $2.8 Billion Settlement That Could Change College Sports

May 23, 2024, 12:43 PM

NCAA-Logo-Basketball...

A Pac-12 basketball tournament logo is shown on basketballs before a semifinal game between the Arizona Wildcats and the Oregon Ducks in the Pac-12 Conference basketball tournament at T-Mobile Arena on March 15, 2024 in Las Vegas, Nevada. (Photo by David Becker/Getty Images)

(Photo by David Becker/Getty Images)

AP – The NCAA and Big Ten Conference leadership approved a $2.8 billion settlement of antitrust claims Wednesday, moving college athletics closer to some of the most sweeping changes in its history.

NCAA Votes To Accept $2.8 Billion Settlement

The NCAA completed its three-part approval process late Wednesday, with its 15-member Board of Governors voting unanimously to accept the proposal — with one member abstaining — according to two people with direct knowledge of the vote who spoke to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity because the NCAA was not publicly revealing its internal process.

The settlement could resolve three major antitrust lawsuits against the NCAA that carry the threat of some $20 billion in damages, a blow that would cripple the organization. The settlement includes dramatic changes to the NCAA’s amateur sports model, including allowing revenue-sharing by schools with their athletes.

RELATED: Big Sky Commissioner Tom Wistrcill Says House V. NCAA Legal Settlement Is Flawed

Attorneys for the plaintiffs in House v. the NCAA gave the defendants a Thursday deadline to agree to a settlement. Southeastern Conference and Pac-12 presidents were scheduled to meet during the day to consider the deal.

The Big 12 and Atlantic Coast Conference presidential boards voted to move forward with the settlement on Tuesday. Big Ten presidents voted to approve the deal Wednesday during spring meetings in Los Angeles, a person with direct knowledge of the decision told AP on condition of anonymity because the conference was not making its internal discussions public.

As the leagues and NCAA marched toward the settlement, a fourth antitrust case presents a potential complication.

U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney in Colorado ruled Thursday that Fontenot vs. the NCAA will stay in her court instead of being moved to California and combined with one of the other antitrust lawsuits that could be covered by the settlement.

Attorney for the plaintiffs in Fontenot said they won’t know whether their claims would be covered by the settlement until they have all the details of the proposal.

“One way or the other, they have to deal with us or I just don’t see how a settlement ultimately gets done,” George Zelcs, one of the plaintiffs’ attorneys, told AP on Wednesday. “They have to either include us or get an order that requires us to be involved in it. All of which we have arguments against as well.”

The NCAA and five conferences named in the House vs. NCAA lawsuit that is at the center of settlement talks have asked Sweeney to combine the Fontenot case with Carter vs. the NCAA, which is being heard in the Northern District of California.

Under terms of the proposed settlement, the NCAA would pay $2.77 billion over 10 years to former and current college athletes who were denied by now-defunct rules the ability to earn money from endorsement and sponsorship deals dating to 2016. The NCAA and conferences also would agree to establish a revenue-sharing system, with schools allowed — though not required — to spend about $21 million a year on their athletes. That number could grow over time if revenue increases.

House and Hubbard v. NCAA have already been combined in the Northern District of California and are being overseen by U.S. Judge Claudia Wilken, who has ruled against the NCAA in several high-profile antitrust cases in recent years.

Carter is being overseen by U.S. Judge Richard Seeborg. Fontenot would be added to Seeborg’s cases.

Former Colorado football player Alex Fontenot filed his lawsuit last November, claiming NCAA rules have illegally prevented college athletes from earning their fair share of the millions of dollars in revenue schools bring in. Garrett Broshuis, Zelcs’ colleague at the law firm Korein Tillery, said the Fontenot case should not be combined with the other three because they have fundamental differences.

“House was focused on name, image and likeness issues, which is really just a small segment of the overall revenue that the NCAA and the conferences and their members are bringing in,” Broshuis told AP. “Our case is instead focusing on what would be the true free-market value of the services being provided by these athletes.”

Broshuis said the Carter case focuses on just basketball and football players from Power Five conferences — ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-12 and SEC.

“Whereas the Fontenot proposed class is broader than that. Revenue is revenue no matter what sport,” he said.

The House case is a class-action lawsuit that seeks back pay for college athletes who were denied name, image and likeness compensation dating to 2016. The NCAA lifted its ban on athletes earning NIL money in 2021.

Steve Berman, one of the lead attorneys in House, said in a statement to AP the issues in Fontenot completely overlap with the other cases and the settlement — if approved — “will release all of their claims.”

“And as for their claim they are waiting to see if they want to be part of it, they already laid out objections to the court in Colorado without even seeing the agreement, a completely irresponsible thing to do,” Berman said. “Even more so when they haven’t contributed to the momentum that allowed us to accomplish this as opposed to being Johnny come lately.”

Download the new & improved KSL Sports app from Utah’s sports leader. You can stream live radio, video and stay up to date on all of your favorite teams.

NCAA

utah state washington state...

Tanner Tripp

Utah State’s Defensive Struggles Continue In Loss To Washington State

The Aggies’ defensive struggles continued as they allowed the Cougars to score touchdowns in every quarter. Washington State racked up the score to 49 points to the Aggies’ 28, winning by three touchdowns.

2 hours ago

BYU @ Utah...

Patrick Kinahan

PK: BYU-Utah Rivalry One-Ups Itself With Legendary Game

After nine consecutive losses to its dreaded rival, the BYU Cougars have now won two consecutive games against the University of Utah.

2 hours ago

byu utah social media...

Tanner Tripp

Social Media Reacts To BYU’s Wild Victory Over Utah

The BYU Cougars defeated the Utah Utes on a last-second field goal from Will Ferrin, keeping their undefeated season alive and securing their first win at Rice-Eccles Stadium since 2006. College football experts and fans alike took to social media to react to the wild ending in Salt Lake.

3 hours ago

Mark Harlan Utah Athletics...

Brian Preece

Utah AD Mark Harlan Outraged Following Utah’s Loss To BYU

The Utah Utes are unhappy with how Saturday night's rivalry matchup with BYU finished or with some of the calls that led to a last-second game-winning Cougar field goal. 

3 hours ago

byu utah will ferrin...

Steve Bartle, Mitch Harper, and Chandler Holt

BYU, Will Ferrin Beat Utah On Last Second Field Goal To Remain Undefeated

To BYU and Utah fans, this game was nothing but another signature moment in the history of this storied rivalry.

3 hours ago

SALT LAKE CITY, UT - NOVEMBER 9: Jake Retzlaff #12 of the Brigham Young Cougars pitches the ball un...

Steve Bartle

INSTANT TAKEAWAYS: Victory snatched from Utah, fall to BYU 22-21

SALT LAKE CITY— After holding onto a lead for most of the game, a questionable holding penalty ultimately cost the Utes the win. Still, Utah was unable to score any second-half points, and the Cougars clawed their way back to ultimately snatch victory from the Utes. The Cougars leave Rice-Eccles Stadium with a 22-21 victory, […]

3 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Spanish Fork H.S....

Spanish Fork Advances After Comeback Win Over Park City

The Spanish Fork Dons completed a thrilling comeback to beat the Park City Miners 30-24 in the UHSAA quarterfinals.

...

Northern Utah High School Player of the Week – Week 12

The John Watson Northern Utah High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school football player in all of Northern Utah, honoring their exceptional performances on the gridiron.

salt lake county player of the week...

Salt Lake County High School Player of the Week – Week 12

The Hercules Salt Lake County High School Player of the Week is celebrating the best high school football player in Salt Lake County, honoring their exceptional performances on the gridiron.

game night live...

How To Watch Game Night Live: Park City Miners @ Spanish Fork Dons

Round three of the UHSAA football playoffs is on tap with spectacular playoff matchups around the Beehive State. Winners move on to the semifinals next weekend, and the 2024 high school football season inches toward its end.

Mr. Mac Utah County High School Player of the Week...

Utah County High School Player of the Week – Week 12

The Mr. Mac Utah County High School Player of the Week is awarded each week to the top prep football players in Utah County. It honors athletes for their performances on the gridiron.

Farmington High School...

American Fork Outlasts Farmington In Defensive Battle

Twelfth-seeded American Fork put together a stout defensive performance, shutting down the Farmington Phoenix in a 21-17 win.

NCAA Votes To Accept $2.8 Billion Settlement That Could Change College Sports