Utah Football Putting All Eggs In Costelli Basket

Feb 12, 2021, 2:45 PM
Kyle Whittingham vs. UCLA #2...
Utah Utes head coach Kyle Whittingham walks the sidelines after a Utah score as Utah and UCLA play a college football game in Salt Lake City at Rice-Eccles Stadium on Saturday, Nov. 16, 2019. (Scott G Winterton, Deseret News)
(Scott G Winterton, Deseret News)

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah – Utah Football never publicly offered former four-star Corner Canyon quarterback Jaxson Dart, rather, opted to put all of their trust in California product Peter Costelli.

If Costelli works out and wins the starting job at some point in his Utah career then the conversation will never occur.

But, if Costelli struggles and does eventuate in the manner that the coaches had hoped for, a serious question must be asked regarding the evaluation and scouting process for Utah quarterbacks.

Jack Tuttle was the next great quarterback for Utah, or at least, that was the hope. Tuttle never came close to seeing the field at Utah, he threw more interceptions in practice than any other quarterback and was still clearly in need of some tender love and development.

The Utes never offered Zach Wilson because they were relying on Tuttle to provide for them. Wilson grew up a Utah fan and frequented Rice Eccles Stadium often growing up.

Utah did not evaluate the quarterback position accurately in 2016-17, but hindsight is always 20/20.

Fast forward to today and Utah has put itself in the same position it did in 2016. All of their eggs are in one basket.

The issue isn’t that Wilson or Dart didn’t sign with Utah. The issue lies with the fact that Utah never publicly offered them. Wilson is now one of the top quarterback targets entering the 2021 NFL Draft while Tuttle is fighting for playing time at the University of Indiana. Yet, Wilson was never offered a scholarship to play at Utah despite growing up a fan and being in their backyard. How strange.

Tom Hackett and Steve Bartle spoke on the subject during a recent episode of the It’s Utah’s World podcast.

“Utah is playing a risky game,” Hackett said. “I agree, but they have to keep trusting their evaluation process,” Bartle responded.

Hackett and Bartle continued to discuss reasons why Utah is only offering one four star quarterback any given recruiting cycle.

Bartle admits that Utah is not known as a quarterback school and therefore does not have the leeway other schools such as USC or Oregon may have. While Hackett disagreed by stating that Utah needs to act like they are a quarterback school even if they know that they are not.

If Utah is concerned that their main quarterback target may get upset with the program offering other quarterbacks then the chances of that quarterback working out at Utah is slim.

The second a newcomer steps foot on Utah’s campus after signing they are immediately competing with other players at their position. Utah needs a quarterback who is ready for competition and willing to fight every day for his spot on the team.



  • Utah Utes Scoreboard

  • Utah Utes Team Leaders

  • Utah Utes Standings

Utah Utes

Kyle Ireland

Broncos Announce Former Utah Standout To Miss Rest Of Season

Broncos head coach Nathaniel Hackett announced that former Utah OL Garett Bolles would miss the rest of the 2022 season with a broken leg.
17 hours ago
Rose Bowl - UCLA Bruins Football...
Michelle Bodkin

Utah Has Been Dominate Recently In UCLA Series, Will That Be The Case This Weekend?

The Utes and Bruins have met a total of 19 times with UCLA having a lead of 11-8. However, Utah has dominated the series with UCLA not winning a game since 2015, and getting absolutely drubbed in Salt Lake City last year, 44-24. 
17 hours ago
Clark Phillips III - Utah Utes vs. Oregon State...
Jeremy Mauss

Devin Kaufusi: Utah’s Defense Has Been ‘Clicking’ Since Florida Loss

The Utes have allowed just 10.75 points per game since losing to the Gators.
17 hours ago
Tavion Thomas - Utah Utes vs. UCLA...
Michelle Bodkin

Three Things To Watch: #11 Utah Vs. #18 UCLA

SALT LAKE CITY- This weekend’s matchup for #11 Utah will most likely be their biggest test to date since starting the season against Florida and will also go a long way in determining exactly where #18 UCLA sits as well. Both teams have great talent to work with in all phases of the game, but only […]
17 hours ago
Kyle Ireland

Broncos OL Garett Bolles Carted Off During Thursday Night Football

Broncos offensive lineman Garett Bolles suffered an injury and was carted off the field during Thursday Night Football.
2 days ago
Kyle Ireland

Week 6: How To Watch, Stream Or Listen To Local College Football

The No. 16 BYU Cougars and No. 11 Utah Utes play on big stages during Week 6 of the college football season.
2 days ago
Utah Football Putting All Eggs In Costelli Basket