Former Ute, Cougar Debate Greatest Player From Each Program

May 10, 2019, 12:58 PM

Right: Scott Winterton, Deseret News Left: Tom Smart, Deseret News...

Right: Scott Winterton, Deseret News Left: Tom Smart, Deseret News

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah – It’s easy for a former BYU player to talk about the great Cougars of all time and same goes for a former Ute, but can they pick the best players from the rival school? On the Rivals podcast, co-hosts Scott Mitchell, a former Utah quarterback, and Jason Buck, a former BYU defensive end, gave it a shot.

Greats like Alex Smith, Steve Smith, Ziggy Ansah and Kyle Van Noy were a few of the names that got thrown around in the conversation.

“It’s tough, both schools have had so many great players,” Mitchell concluded.

Utah’s Best?

Jason Buck, co-host of Rivals and former BYU defensive end and Outland Trophy winner, began with a disclaimer.

“The best athletes are on the defensive side of the ball, so that eliminates any offensive players,” said Buck.

He mentioned if he was picking quarterbacks Alex Smith and Brian Johnson would be high on the list, intentionally (and jokingly) leaving out Mitchell.

He went on to give Mitchell credit for “turning the entire program around and beating BYU for the first time in years.” That game was in 1988.

Buck listed Eric Weddle, a free safety who had a productive career with the Baltimore Ravens and now plays for the Los Angeles Rams, and Steve Smith, a receiver who had a successful, 16-year NFL career.


Mitchell brought up an important point. Is the duo judging “the best” by the career they had after college or only what they did while playing college football? Buck admitted to weighing both factors in his choices.

“Steve Smith didn’t have a great career at Utah,” Mitchell pointed out.

In the end, Buck said he will remain faithful to his co-host because he broke the mold at Utah.

“It’d be a real toss up between you and Alex Smith,” Buck concluded.

To which Mitchell responded, “Come on, don’t pick me, I know you are just playing the politics.”

Some other names that were thrown around in the conversation of the greatest Utes included Luther Ellis, Larry Wilson and Marv Fleming.

BYU’s Best?

The first name Mitchell threw out was Ziggy Ansah, who spent six seasons with the Detroit Lions and recently signed a contract with the Seattle Seahawks, because he was a “freak talent.”

“You’ve got to be kidding me,” Buck yelled.

The only consensus All-American player in BYU history is Buck.

“I’ll admit, in your time at BYU you made it happen,” said Mitchell.

In the end, Mitchell picked Jim McMahon, from a “purely talent perspective.”

Buck wasn’t thrilled.

Subscribe to the Rivals podcast wherever podcasts are found or on the KSL Sports app.



  • Utah Utes Scoreboard

  • Utah Utes Team Leaders

  • Utah Utes Standings

  • BYU Cougars Scoreboard

  • BYU Cougars Team Leaders

  • BYU Cougars Standings


joe burrow bengals...

Madisan Hinkhouse, KSL Sports

Former Bengals: Joe Burrow Should Refuse To Play For Cincinnati

Scott Mitchell and Jason Buck both played for the Cincinnati Bengals. They agree that former LSU quarterback Joe Burrow should do everything he can to avoid playing for the Bengals.

4 years ago

Jordan Love - Utah State...

Madisan Hinkhouse, KSL Sports

Former NFL Quarterback: Jordan Love Should Not Enter NFL Draft

Utah State quarterback Jordan Love is taking the same steps former NFL quarterback Scott Mitchell took as he prepares to forgo his senior season and enter the NFL Draft. Mitchell's advice to Love? Don't do it.

4 years ago

Kyle Whittingham and Kalani Sitake...

Madisan Hinkhouse, KSL Sports

BYU Helps Utah By Playing USC One Week Before Utes

"Kalani will do extra favors for Kyle because they are friends."

5 years ago

David Shaw, Stanford...

Jeremy Mauss, KSL Sports

Stanford’s David Shaw Understands Value Of Return Missionaries

Stanford head coach likes what return missionaries can bring on and off the field.

5 years ago

Bradlee Anae #6 (Photo by George Frey/Getty Images) 
Jaylon Johnson #1 (Photo by Thearon W. Henders...

Madisan Hinkhouse, KSL Sports

Utes, Aggies Land Players On Top 100 List – BYU Left Out

Sports Illustrated featured a few Utes and an Aggie on their list of the "Top 100 College Football Players"  but no Cougars made the list.

5 years ago

SALT LAKE CITY, UT - OCTOBER 7: Head coach of the Utah Utes Kyle Whittingham watches from the sidel...

Madisan Hinkhouse, KSL Sports

Lack Of Offense Puts Whittingham Third Among Pac-12 Coaches

Kyle Whittingham came in at number three in a ranking of Pac-12 coaches. Could lack of production on the offensive side of the ball be the reason he missed the top spots?

5 years ago

Sponsored Articles


KSL Sports

KSL Sports Newsletter: Sign Up Now

Sign up today for the KSL Sports newsletter. Get the latest Utah sports news delivered to your inbox.


KSL Sports

Jazz Notes Newsletter: Sign Up Now

Sign up today for the Jazz Notes newsletter. Get insider analysis, game recaps and opportunities to win tickets!

Follow @kslsports...

The Road Home Mediathon 2023

The KSL Sports Zone and KSLSports.com are proud to support the all-day Mediathon 2023 at the Road Home, an annual tradition to raise money and other essential items for the Road Home, a Homeless Shelter.

3 kids wearing real salt lake jerseys smiling...

Real Salt Lake

6 Reasons You Need to Experience a RSL Matchday

RSL Games are a great way to spend time with your family with fun activities, good food, and traditions you can only experience at the field.

High angle view of the beautiful Rose Bowl Stadium...

KSL Digital Sales

How to Prepare for the 2023 Rose Bowl

Everything you need to know to plan your 2023 Rose Bowl trip in Pasadena, California. This year, the Utes will face Penn State.


KSL Digital Sales

Notable Moments From The Utah Jazz Season… So Far

At the beginning of the season, the Utah Jazz were second to last. Now they rank in the top 10 teams in the Western Conference.

Former Ute, Cougar Debate Greatest Player From Each Program