Why The College Football Recruiting System Is Broken

Feb 19, 2019, 7:31 PM | Updated: 7:45 pm

(Photo by Streeter Lecka/Getty Images)...

(Photo by Streeter Lecka/Getty Images)

(Photo by Streeter Lecka/Getty Images)

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah – The college football recruiting process is an exciting time for high school athletes. Where will they go? How can they contribute? However, the recruiting process itself is flawed, in that it favors what are often multi-million dollar institutions, and not always the best interest of the individual themselves.

From the time children can talk and learn, their told by adults not to lie. Yet, somehow many college football coaches do it, and they get away with it? They aren’t unique in this, but we are talking about grown men who make copious amounts of money annually, lying to young men because they know these teenagers don’t know any better.

Here is where it gets even crazier – outside of winning games, a coach’s biggest job is recruiting the student athlete. Yet, the pressure to get the best players and win lead many lie throughout the entire process.

🔊 LISTEN: Why former Ute, current Miami Dolphin Isaac Asiata hates recruiting

On the Special Forces Podcast, former Utah offensive lineman Isaac Asiata said he wasn’t a fan of the recruiting process. What doesn’t he like about it?

“Everything… I believe that kids deserve scholarships. I believe that they deserve success, but I don’t believe that they deserve to have their butts kissed by the coaches,” he said. “It’s kind of fake.”

Hypothetical Example In College Sports

Let’s assume you’re a high profile recruit and have many schools that are after your talents. One school comes to you and tells you that they think you are so talented that they can guarantee playing time your freshman year. Another school decides to tell the truth and inform you that they are a program that thrives on competition and you will benefit from it.

There is no guarantee you will play your freshman year. It all depends on your personal development and how you stack up against the rest of the playing group at your particular position. Which team are you going to choose? The decision isn’t that hard, is it? After all, you are a young adult who doesn’t know any better, and has a hard time reading what is the truth and what isn’t.

“You tell a kid he’s great, but you’re also brutally honest with him, a lot of kids these days are going to take your name off their list of schools they want to go to,” said Asiata.

How Would This Translate In The Workplace?

Think of it this way: if you went to a job interview, say for, a marketing job and the person conducting the interview tells you they want to hire you as the director of marketing. Then you go to another company and they tell you that you are going to start as an entry level marketing assistant. Which job are you going to choose?

Obviously, the company that offered you the director of marketing job. So, you accept the director position, and on your first day you realize you are the equivalent of an entry level marketing coordinator. You are not going to be very happy. In fact, you are going to be so unhappy you probably start looking for jobs again.

NCAA Rules Need To Change

The rules created by the NCAA generally favor the institutions. They need to change to favor the student-athlete. Without parameters in place, it’s the entire college athletics versus individual teenagers.

In the landscape of college athletics, if you wanted to start looking for other schools to attend, now you have the NCAA that dictates things. According to their rules, you have to sit out a year before you can play. (Granted, this rule only applies if you have not received your undergraduate degree, which will normally take about 3 years to complete).

How is that fair to the student-athlete? Shouldn’t the school that made false promises be held accountable for their actions?

One solution would be for the NCAA to require coaches to record every conversation with recruits. Then, let the student-athlete transfer if it’s determined they were mislead.

The easiest solution would be for the NCAA to lighten up their policies to make it easier for student-athletes to transfer – maybe not in all situations, but certainly there are times when the transfer is in the best interest of the student.


  • Utah Utes Scoreboard

  • Utah Utes Team Leaders

  • Utah Utes Standings

  • BYU Cougars Scoreboard

  • BYU Cougars Team Leaders

  • BYU Cougars Standings

  • Utah State Aggies Scoreboard

  • Utah State Aggies Team Leaders

  • Utah State Aggies Standings

Special Forces Gang

Members of the Alabama Crimson Tide celebrate after winning the CFP National Championship presented...

Tom Hackett, KSL Sports

The Answer To Fixing College Football Bowl Season Is In Vegas

How the NCAA could create a more exciting postseason.

5 years ago

Photo: Josh Tilton, KSL Sports...

KSL Sports

Utah In Peach Bowl Leads Way For Local College Football Postseason Predictions

It has been an amusing season for college football in the state of Utah, but where will all of our teams end up? The KSL Sports team has some ideas.

5 years ago

Running back Zack Moss #2 of the Utah Utes rushes the football against the Arizona State Sun Devils...

Tom Hackett, KSL Sports

Moss Underwent Concussion Protocol: Here’s What The Protocol Entails

Zack Moss was targeted midway through the second quarter from a hit that is deserving of a multiple game suspension. He entered concussion protocol.

5 years ago

Isaac Asiata #54 of the Utah Utes holds the trophy up to the crowd after a win against the Indiana ...

Tom Hackett, KSL Sports

Former Ute, Dolphin Assures Fans Utah’s O Line Issues Will Work Out

During the first episode together, we talked about the struggles on the offensive line and where it all went wrong.

5 years ago

Photo: Steve Griffin / Deseret News...

Andy Phillips, KSL Sports

Why A Former Ute Kicker Is Concerned (And Not) With Utah’s Kicking Woes

If all else fails, Ben Lennon can put it through the pipes.

5 years ago

Tom Hackett #33 of the Utah Utes watches his kick during their game against the Michigan Wolverines...

Madisan Hinkhouse, KSL Sports

Former Utah Punter Included On Greatest-Ever College Football Team

Tom Hackett received honorable mention.

5 years ago

Sponsored Articles


KSL Sports

Utah Hockey Newsletter: Sign Up Now

Want to get the latest info on Utah's newest sports franchise? Sign up for the Utah Hockey newsletter!

Hans & Scotty's Day of Adoption...

Hans & Scotty’s Day Of Adoption

Join the KSL Sports Zone for Hans & Scotty's Day of Adoption, in partnership with the Humane Society of Utah, on June 25th, 2024!


KSL Sports

KSL Sports Newsletter: Sign Up Now

Sign up today for the KSL Sports newsletter. Get the latest Utah sports news delivered to your inbox.


KSL Sports

Jazz Notes Newsletter: Sign Up Now

Sign up today for the Jazz Notes newsletter. Get insider analysis, game recaps and opportunities to win tickets!

3 kids wearing real salt lake jerseys smiling...

Real Salt Lake

6 Reasons You Need to Experience a RSL Matchday

RSL Games are a great way to spend time with your family with fun activities, good food, and traditions you can only experience at the field.

High angle view of the beautiful Rose Bowl Stadium...

KSL Digital Sales

How to Prepare for the 2023 Rose Bowl

Everything you need to know to plan your 2023 Rose Bowl trip in Pasadena, California. This year, the Utes will face Penn State.

Why The College Football Recruiting System Is Broken